When to Replace a Garage Door Instead of Repairing It

Most garage door problems can be repaired. Some cannot. This guide helps you decide.

When repair makes sense

• One part is broken. A spring or cable or roller or hinge can be replaced.
• The panels are straight and solid.
• The door is not very old.
• The problem is new and not a pattern.

When replacement makes sense

• Several panels are cracked or rotted or badly rusted.
• The door has been repaired again and again.
• Parts for your door are hard to find.
• The door is out of line after an impact.
• You want better insulation or a quieter door.
• The door looks worn and hurts the look of the house.

Questions to ask yourself

1. How old is the door?
2. Is the damage in one part or in the whole door?
3. How often has it needed work?
4. Is the garage heated or used as a workspace?
5. Do you plan to sell the house soon?

Ask for a clear explanation

A good technician will tell you what is wrong and show you the damage. Ask what a repair will fix and what it will not. Ask what could fail next. If you are told to replace the door ask why. If you are not sure ask for a second opinion.

How we handle it

We repair first. We suggest a new door only when repair no longer makes sense. Read about new garage door installation if you are leaning that way. For a single broken part see our pages on spring replacement and cable repair.